Why Two "Surlyn" Grades Can Fail the Same Seal Test
A sealant layer that runs cleanly on one packaging line and gives weak seals or stringing on the next is often blamed on machine settings. In ionomer resins, the more common cause is that the two bags were never the same grade. Within the Surlyn family, the neutralising ion (sodium or zinc), the melt flow rate and the softening point move independently: two grades can share a density of 0.94 g/cm³ and a Surlyn name, yet differ by more than an order of magnitude in MFR. This grade map pulls together the twelve ionomer grades we actually list, with the published typical values from each product page, so you can shortlist on data instead of on a brand name. If you are building a multilayer structure, start with the Surlyn ionomer resin category and work down to the grade.
Contents
- What an ionomer actually is
- The twelve grades: published values side by side
- Sodium vs zinc: how the choice gets made
- Reading MFR and thermal numbers together
- Four common cross-referencing mistakes
- What to put in the RFQ
- FAQ
What an Ionomer Actually Is
An ionomer is an ethylene–methacrylic acid (EMAA) copolymer in which part of the acid groups is neutralised with metal ions. The ionic groups form reversible associations inside the polymer, which is why these resins combine clarity with toughness, hot tack and resistance to oily or fatty foods. The metal ion is not a minor detail on the data sheet: sodium- and zinc-neutralised grades are specified for different seal behaviours and different adhesion targets. One grade in our catalogue, SK Primacor IO 3701, is described by its manufacturer as an EAA-based ionomer rather than an EMAA Surlyn type — it belongs on the same shortlist, but it is not a drop-in Surlyn equivalent. Grades whose product page does not state the ion type are labelled accordingly below; we do not infer it.
The Twelve Grades: Published Values Side by Side
All figures below are the typical values already published on the linked POLYVALA product pages, compiled from manufacturer data sheets and grade documentation. Where a value has not been published for a grade, the cell reads "—" rather than being filled from a neighbouring grade. MFR conditions are stated on the individual product pages where available (190 °C / 2.16 kg for the grades that carry a test condition); typical values are not specification limits and are confirmed against the batch COA before shipment.
| Grade | Chemistry / ion | Density (g/cm³) | MFR (g/10 min) | Tm (°C) | Vicat (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dow 1601 | EMAA ionomer (ion type not stated) | 0.940 | 1.3 | 98 | 74 |
| Dow 1601-2 | Sodium-ion EMAA ionomer | 0.94 | 1.3 | 98 | 74 |
| Dow 1652 | EMAA ionomer (ion type not stated) | 0.940 | 5.5 | 100 | 79 |
| SURLYN 1652SB | Zinc ionomer of EMAA | 0.94 | 4.6 | 101 | — |
| Dow 1652SR | Zinc-ion EMAA ionomer | 0.94 | 5.4 | 100 | 79 |
| Dow 1702 | Sodium-ion EMAA ionomer | 0.950 | 14 | 93 | 65 |
| Dow 1707 | Sodium-ion EMAA ionomer | 0.950 | 0.9 | 90 | 58 |
| Dow 1857 | Zinc ionomer (ethylene–MAA–AA) | 0.94 | 4 | 87 | 56 |
| SK Primacor IO 3701 | EAA-based ionomer (SK) | 0.94 | 5.2 | 95 | — |
| Dow 72D727 | Modified ionomer, Surlyn family | 0.94 | 3.5 | 94 | — |
| Dow 72D799 | Modified ionomer, Surlyn family | 0.932 | 2.9 | 93 | — |
| Dow 72D811 | Modified ionomer, Surlyn family | 0.93 | 6.9 | 94 | — |
Additional published values: Dow 1857 lists tensile strength 31 MPa, elongation at break 500 % and haze 7 %. SURLYN 1652SB and SK Primacor IO 3701 carry MFR conditions of 190 °C / 2.16 kg (ASTM D1238) and density by ASTM D792 on their product pages.
Sodium vs Zinc: How the Choice Gets Made
- Sodium-neutralised grades — in our catalogue, 1601-2, 1702 and 1707. These are commonly specified where clarity, hot tack and seal-through-contamination behaviour matter in food packaging sealant layers. Dow 1601-2 is listed for meat, seafood, cheese and deli/cooked-food applications, coextrusion sealant layers and low-temperature resistance.
- Zinc-neutralised grades — 1652SB, 1652SR and 1857. SURLYN 1652SB is specifically published as a peelable seal layer for high-speed snack, coffee and dairy packaging lines; zinc types are also widely used where adhesion to foil or paper and abrasion resistance are part of the brief.
- Lithium-neutralised grades — we currently list none. If your existing specification calls for a lithium ionomer, tell us the grade and we will confirm availability rather than substitute a sodium grade and assume equivalence.
- Modified Surlyn-family ionomers — the 72D727 / 72D799 / 72D811 group is described on its product pages as modified ionomer. Their published densities (0.94 / 0.932 / 0.93 g/cm³) and MFRs (3.5 / 2.9 / 6.9) differ enough that they should be treated as distinct grades, not variants of one resin.
Reading MFR and Thermal Numbers Together
Melt flow is the fastest way to disqualify a candidate. Among the sodium grades, 1707 is published at 0.9 g/10 min while 1702 is at 14 g/10 min — same ion type, same 0.950 g/cm³ density, and a fifteen-fold difference in flow. That gap decides whether a resin suits a high-output coating or extrusion process or a higher-melt-strength operation. The 1652 cluster is tighter but still not interchangeable: 1652 at 5.5, 1652SR at 5.4 and 1652SB at 4.6 g/10 min, with 1652SB additionally specified as a peelable seal grade.
Thermal values separate the same grades again. Published melting points across the twelve run from 87 °C (1857) to 101 °C (1652SB), and Vicat softening points from 56 °C (1857) to 79 °C (1652 and 1652SR). A lower softening point can widen a heat-seal window but narrow the margin in hot-fill, retort or warm-distribution conditions. For retort structures, read this together with our EVOH retort sterilisation guide and the retort flexible packaging application hub, because the sealant layer is only one layer of the structure. Where Vicat has not been published for a grade, we leave it blank rather than estimating it.
Four Common Cross-Referencing Mistakes
- Treating 1652, 1652SB and 1652SR as one grade. They have different published MFRs, different melt points and different stated applications; 1652SB is a zinc peelable-seal grade.
- Shortlisting on density alone. Most of the twelve sit at 0.94 g/cm³, so density does not distinguish a sodium sealant resin from a zinc peelable grade.
- Assuming every "ionomer" is a Surlyn EMAA type. SK Primacor IO 3701 is an EAA-based ionomer; Dow 1857 is described as an ethylene–methacrylic acid–acrylic acid zinc ionomer.
- Reading a typical value as a guarantee. The table shows published typicals. The binding document for a shipment is the batch COA, alongside the current official TDS and SDS — see our quality and documents page for what accompanies an order.
What to Put in the RFQ
- Exact grade name and, where known, the neutralising ion — not just "Surlyn sealant resin".
- Target MFR with its test condition (190 °C / 2.16 kg where applicable), plus any density or Vicat limits your line requires.
- Layer structure and adjacent materials (PE, EVOH, PA, foil, paper), layer thickness, and whether the seal must be peelable or weld-type.
- Conversion route: coextrusion, cast or blown film, extrusion coating, lamination or compounding.
- End use and thermal exposure: ambient, chilled, hot-fill or retort; fatty or oily contents.
- Destination market and the documents your customs or quality team needs: TDS, SDS, COA and any applicable declarations.
Send the list to our application engineers through the contact page; we shortlist 2–3 grades and confirm each against the current manufacturer TDS before quoting.
Related Reading
- Tie-Layer Compound Selection: PE-g-MAH vs PP-g-MAH vs EAA
- Bondine vs Bynel vs Primacor vs Igetabond: Tie-Layer Brand Cross-Reference
- POE Grade Map: Engage vs Exact vs Tafmer vs Queo vs Lucene
- Retort Flexible Packaging Material Solutions
- Quality & Documents: COA, TDS, SDS and supporting test reports
FAQ
Is a zinc ionomer always better for peelable seals?
Not by definition. SURLYN 1652SB is published specifically as a peelable seal layer for high-speed lines, but peel behaviour depends on the layer structure, seal jaw conditions and the mating layer. Confirm the grade on a line trial.
Can I substitute 1652SR for 1652?
The published MFRs are close (5.4 vs 5.5 g/10 min) and both list 100 °C Tm and 79 °C Vicat, but 1652SR is described as a zinc-ion grade while 1652's product page does not state an ion type. Treat it as a qualification trial, not a drop-in.
Do you list lithium ionomers?
No. None of the twelve grades currently on our site is described as lithium-neutralised. Ask us for availability if your specification requires one.
Are these values specification limits?
No. They are published typical values. The batch COA is the binding document for a shipment; the current official TDS and SDS are available on request.
References
- ASTM D1238 — Standard Test Method for Melt Flow Rates of Thermoplastics by Extrusion Plastometer.
- ASTM D792 — Standard Test Method for Density and Specific Gravity of Plastics by Displacement.
- ASTM D1525 / ISO 306 — Vicat softening temperature of plastics.
- ISO 11357 — Plastics — Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC), melting behaviour.
- Manufacturer technical data sheets and grade documentation for Dow SURLYN ionomer resins and SK Primacor IO 3701, as compiled on the linked POLYVALA product pages.
About this article
Written by the technical team at Shanghai Polyvala Plastics, a sourcing and compounding partner for flexible-packaging converters since 2013. We cross-reference ionomer grades against supplier data sheets and real coextrusion and sealing lines, not just datasheets. Questions about your specific structure? Request the TDS, SDS and COA for any grade linked above, or contact our application engineers for a structure-specific recommendation.