Why a "Test Report" Alone Proves Very Little
Buyers of polymer resins increasingly receive a PDF the moment they ask for compliance documents: a RoHS report, a REACH statement, a PAHs or phthalates result. The instinct is to file it and move on. But a test report is only evidence once you can answer five questions about it — who issued it, what exactly was tested, which version of the rule was applied, when it was issued, and whether the sample has anything to do with the grade you are actually buying. This guide walks through those five questions using the structure of real third-party reports, and shows where a supporting report ends and a product certification begins. When you request documents from us, the same checklist applies to what you receive.
Contents
- What a third-party test report is — and is not
- The five fields to check first
- 1. Who issued it: the laboratory
- 2. What was tested: the sample
- 3. Which version of the rule
- 4. When it was issued
- 5. The scope and the conclusion
- Red flags we see repeatedly
- What to ask for in your RFQ
- FAQ
What a Third-Party Test Report Is — and Is Not
A third-party test report is a laboratory's record of what it observed in a specific sample on a specific date, against a specific method. It is not a licence, not a product certification, and not a guarantee about future batches. Those are different documents with different weight.
Three distinctions matter in practice:
- Supporting report vs certification. A report showing that one submitted sample passed RoHS limits is a supporting test report. A product certification (or a regulated-market declaration of conformity) involves a defined scheme, ongoing surveillance and a licence to use a mark. A single PDF does not confer the latter.
- Sample vs grade. The result applies to the sample described on page one. If that sample is "PVC, white pellets" and you are buying a POE or an ionomer, the report says nothing about your material — however genuine it is.
- Applicant vs seller. The applicant named on the report is who commissioned the test. It may be a compounder, a trader or an affiliated company, not the entity selling to you. Read the name; do not assume.
None of this makes reports useless. It makes them useful in the right scope: as one input in a supplier's document trail, alongside the grade TDS, the batch COA and a clear statement of which materials the report actually covers.
The Five Fields to Check First
Turn to page one and read these five fields in order. If any is missing or ambiguous, the document is not yet evidence.
| Field | What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Laboratory | Full legal name and address | Establishes who is accountable for the result |
| Report number | A unique identifier, ideally traceable | Lets you ask the lab to confirm the document |
| Issue date | Day, month, year | Regulations and lists change; old reports go stale |
| Sample description | Name, model, colour, form | Ties the result to the material you are buying |
| Standard / conclusion | Method, version, pass/fail | Defines what "passed" actually means |
1. Who Issued It: the Laboratory
Start with the issuer's exact legal name, not the logo. In the reports we have on file, two different laboratories appear: Shenzhen Alpha Product Testing Co., Ltd. (深圳阿尔法商品检验有限公司), whose report numbers begin with the letter A, and Shenzhen Deesev Testing International Corp (深圳市德泽威技术检测有限公司), whose report numbers begin with DTI. Both are real testing companies; neither is SGS. We say that plainly because "SGS report" is a phrase that gets attached to Chinese supplier documents loosely, and buyers later discover the mismatch during an audit.
Two things to verify: the name on the report matches the name you were told, and the lab is accredited for the specific test. An ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation is scope-specific — a lab can be accredited for RoHS but not for a given PAHs method. If your market or customer requires an accredited report, ask which accredited scope the test fell under, not just whether the lab "has 17025".
2. What Was Tested: the Sample
This is the field most often ignored, and the one that most often breaks the chain of evidence. A genuine, correctly issued report can still be irrelevant to your order.
Concrete examples from the documents in our own archive:
- A 2019 report whose sample is polycarbonate (PC), model IRY2200, with a list of "reference information" grade numbers in the sample block.
- Reports from 2022 and 2023 whose samples are PC and PPS, commissioned by an affiliated compounder under two similar report-number prefixes.
- A 2020 set covering PP (polypropylene) and PVC separately, with each material tested under its own report numbers — the PP result is not reused for PVC.
- 2025 and 2026 DTI reports whose sample is explicitly PVC (polyvinyl chloride).
Notice the pattern: each material has its own report set. That is how it should work. When a single report claims to cover POE, EVA, COC, EVOH and ionomer at once, ask how one submitted sample can represent five chemically different families. Our own quality & documents page states exactly which materials its listed reports cover, and we apply the same rule to any document we send.
3. Which Version of the Rule
Compliance lists are not static. A report is only current against the version of the rule named in it. The archive illustrates the drift clearly:
| Test | Older reports | Newer reports | What changed |
|---|---|---|---|
| REACH SVHC | 201 SVHC substances (2019) | 233 (2022–23), 250 (2025) | The candidate list grows; a 2019 screen does not cover later additions |
| PAHs | AfPS GS 2014:01 PAK (2019 reports) | AFPS GS 2019:01 PAK (2025 reports) | Test method and category criteria were revised |
| Phthalates | 17P (2019–2020) | 18P (2022 onward) | An additional phthalate was included in the scope |
| RoHS | Directive 2011/65/EU | Same directive plus amendments | Check the amendment list and the four restricted phthalates |
So "we have a REACH report" is not a complete answer. The useful answer names the SVHC count and the list date. If your customer requires the current candidate list, a report screening 201 substances will not satisfy them even though it passed when issued.
4. When It Was Issued
Date matters twice. First, against the rule: as above, an older report may test against an older list. Second, against your relationship with the supplier: most buyers treat compliance documents as having a practical shelf life of one to three years, and some customers insist on reports issued within the last twelve months. A 2019 report is not "false" — it is simply old, and it should be presented as historical supporting evidence, not as current status.
When you receive a report, also compare the date with the sample receipt and test dates on the same page. They should form a sensible sequence. Gaps or impossible ordering are worth a question.
5. The Scope and the Conclusion
The conclusion is a short word — "Pass", "合格", "ND" (not detected) — and it means only what the test request above it defines. Read the request line together with the result:
- Pass against a limit. RoHS and REACH results are pass/fail against stated concentration limits. "Pass" means the sample was below those limits under that method.
- ND / not detected. This refers to the method's detection limit, not to a philosophical zero. Ask for the detection limit if your specification is tight.
- Qualified pass. Some reports add a note — for example a PAHs result whose judgement depends on a material category defined on a later page. Follow the note. A pass with a category assumption is not the same as an unconditional pass.
Finally, check that the report number, sample name and result agree across all pages. A conclusion on page one that does not match the data table on page three is a reason to pause, not to file.
Red Flags We See Repeatedly
- Wrong lab name. A document described verbally as "SGS" that turns out to be issued by a different laboratory. The report may be fine; the description is not.
- Sample family mismatch. A PVC or PC report offered as proof that a POE, EVA or ionomer grade is compliant.
- Grade re-labelling. A report whose sample model is one grade, while the seller presents it as covering a different grade with a similar name.
- Stale list. An REACH report screening an older SVHC count presented as current without qualification.
- Borrowed identity. An applicant different from the seller, with no explanation of the relationship.
- Image-only documents. A scanned picture with no searchable text, no verifiable report number and no way to check the underlying data.
- One report, many grades. A single sample claimed to certify an entire product catalogue.
None of these is resolved by asking for "more certificates". They are resolved by asking for the right document, for the right grade, with the fields filled in.
What to Ask for in Your RFQ
Four lines get you most of the way:
- "Please send the current TDS and the batch COA for this specific grade."
- "For any third-party report, state the laboratory, report number, issue date and the exact sample name/model tested."
- "Confirm which of the grades I am ordering are actually covered by each report — and which are not."
- "State the test version used: SVHC count and list date, PAHs method, phthalate scope (17P or 18P)."
A supplier who can answer these cleanly is telling you something useful. One who answers with a single generic PDF and "all our materials pass" is telling you something too. For the wider sourcing context — MOQ, samples, freight — see Sourcing Polymer Pellets from China, and for the difference between the two everyday documents see How to Read a TDS and COA.
FAQ
Is a RoHS report a product certification?
No. It is a test result for a submitted sample against RoHS limits. Certification involves a scheme, surveillance and a licence to use a mark. Treat a single report as supporting evidence.
Can one report cover several grades?
Only if those grades were actually represented by the tested sample and the report says so. A "reference information" list of grade numbers is not the same as each grade being tested. Ask for confirmation per grade.
My supplier's report is from 2019. Is it invalid?
Not invalid, but old. It was correct against the rules in force then. For current compliance, ask for a recent report against the current SVHC list and method versions.
The report says "SGS" in the email but a different lab on page one. What now?
Go by page one. Ask the supplier to explain the discrepancy in writing. The report itself may be genuine — the label was simply wrong.
Where do I see which reports cover which POLYVALA grades?
On our quality & documents page. We list the issuing lab, report number, sample, issue date and conclusion, and state the scope in plain language. If a grade you are buying is not covered, we say so rather than implying otherwise.
References
- Directive 2011/65/EU (RoHS 2) and its amending directives — restriction of hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment.
- Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006 (REACH) — Candidate List of Substances of Very High Concern; the list has grown from 201 to 250+ substances over the period covered by the example reports.
- AfPS GS 2014:01 PAK and AFPS GS 2019:01 PAK — test methods and category criteria for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons.
- ISO/IEC 17025 — general requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories; accreditation is scope-specific.
- Structure and fields illustrated using third-party reports held in our document archive (Alpha and DTI reports, 2019–2026). These are supporting test reports on the submitted samples named in each report, not product certifications and not coverage of every grade we list.
About this article
Written by the technical team at Shanghai Polyvala Plastics, a sourcing and compounding partner for flexible-packaging converters since 2013. We treat documents as evidence with a scope, not as decoration. Need the TDS, SDS, batch COA or the specific third-party report for a grade you are evaluating? Request documents here or contact our application engineers — we will tell you exactly what each document does and does not cover.